Reworking an image can be a tough, painful, and aggravating process. Often when I complete an image, it’s because I have brought it to the furthest finishing level I can currently go. Reworking often involves asking for lots of feedback, looking at the image with fresh eyes, and scrutinizing myself meticulously.
Sometimes I am able to do this effectively, other times not. It’s difficult to see specific areas of needed improvement when you’ve put all you can into an image. That being said, it can be a beneficial and rewarding learning process.
For the above images, I decided to try to improve the narrative and color for the first edit. For the second edit I tried to improve the composition so that it didn’t read like two separate stories. There is still more that could be done to improve this image, however at this point I’d be facing diminishing rewards with each edit.
My advice on reworking images:
- Choose images that you’ve had some time away from, but not too much time. A couple months, but not a couple years.
- Too little time and you haven’t learned enough new information that can be applied, too much time and you’ve learned too much. You want to rework the image, not redo it.
- Focus on what you have learned and what you can learn from reworking the images.
- You are testing yourself to see if you have truly learned anything new about color, light, composition, styling, etc…
- Doing this to your old pieces is an easy and quick way to both see and solidify learning improvements.
- Remember the original intent and goal of your image. Try to effectively get that across in a greater way.
- Don’t rework an image too many times unless you see it as a portfolio piece.
- Remember, the goal is learning and the application of learning. After a certain point, the rewards of reworking a piece will be far less than the time involved in reworking it. Be smart about it and know your goals for why you do something.
The biggest benefit of reworking an old image is that it is a quick way to put you into a problem solving mode, rather than an ideation/creative mode.